What Are Backlash and Lost Motion?

Teach Me Please! Ms. Ori
Teach Me Please! Ms. Ori
  • Mr. Vex

    Recently, there has been a growing need for "robots that can replace human work" due to worker shortages.

  • Ms. Ori

    That's right. I've heard a lot of people say not only that they want to buy a robot that is suited for the required task or operation, but also that they want to create their own robot for the application they need. There are also Videos of Articulated Robot Demonstration Units on the website.

  • Mr. Vex

    In fact, I've got a customer who have built his own robot, but is concerned that sometimes it's not able to achieve the positioning which he wants.
    He says he's using a geared motor, but...

  • Ms. Ori

    I wonder if there is a problem with the mechanism. I also wonder about the accuracy of the gearheads. Vex, do you remember what backlash is?

  • Mr. Vex

    I'm not sure I can explain it well.

  • Ms. Ori

    Then let's review it together. That might help you solve your customer's problem.

  • Mr. Vex

    Please!

  • Ms. Ori

    Backlash is the "gaps between the gears according to the design."

  • Mr. Vex

    The word "gaps" doesn't really come with a positive impression to me, but are they necessary?

  • Ms. Ori

    Gaps are needed. If the gears are assembled with no gaps between and pressed tightly together, the load will be too high and the gears won't turn.

  • Mr. Vex

    So that's why the design needs to include appropriate gap space.

  • Ms. Ori

    In unidirectional operation, the same gears keep touching each other, so the gaps won't be an issue. However, when using back-and-forth operation as with robots, the gap between the gears makes it difficult to reach the target position.

    Figure 1 Backlash and Misalignment of Movement Transmission
    Figure 1  Backlash and Misalignment of Movement Transmission
  • Mr. Vex

    I see. But the gaps between the gearheads are a small deviation from the perspective of the entire equipment, right? How do they affect to the robot?

  • Ms. Ori

    Look at Figure 2.
    Can you see that there is a big difference in the misalignment near the motor and at tip of the arm?

    Figure 2 Backlash and Robot Tip Misalignment
    Figure 2  Backlash and Robot Tip Misalignment
  • Mr. Vex

    Oh, you're right. That’s the principle of triangle similarity!

  • Ms. Ori

    It looks like you understand that the backlash affects the misalignment of the robot's tip.
    Robots in particular, require a high level of accuracy, so they often use tapered gears, gears with a special mechanism that sandwiches 2 gears from both directions to minimize the gap (low backlash), or gears shaped so that they can be assembled without gaps (non-backlash). For more information, take a look here.

  • Mr. Vex

    Yes! I think I can make a proposal now.

  • Ms. Ori

    Hold on. For this issue, you'll need to review lost motion as well.

  • Mr. Vex

    What’s lost motion?

  • Ms. Ori

    This is the value measured by a device that measures "maximum difference between the forward and reverse directions when positioning to a certain position." It's determined by JIS Standard, so check it out.

  • Mr. Vex

    So backlash is something you design, on the other hand, lost motion is something you use equipment to measure?

  • Ms. Ori

    Like this robot, the equipment is made up of various mechanical elements. You have to consider the influence of all those factors.

    Figure 3 Lost Motion Image
    Figure 3  Lost Motion Image
  • Mr. Vex

    I see. So that's why we need to measure it.

  • Ms. Ori

    When it comes to determining the desired position with a robot, it is necessary to review not only the accuracy of the motor but also the accuracy of each component.

  • Mr. Vex

    Yes. In order to reduce the effect, I'll suggest to choose the gearheads with the small backlash as possible!

  • Ms. Ori

    That sounds like a good idea. Good luck!

Related Products